Posts

Conservation Easements and Pine Mountain: Favorable Rulings by Court of Appeals and Pending Issues

Image
The IRS has been riding high recently because of several Tax Court victories on “technical” issues in conservation easement disputes. However, several signs exist that the tide might be turning. One of these is the recent decision by the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in Pine Mountain Preserve, LLLP. This article explains the general rules related to conservation easement donations, critical facts from the case, analysis by the Tax Court, overlooked aspects of the initial decision, recent rulings by the Court of Appeals, issues that the Tax Court must now decide on remand, and the positive aspects of the case thus far for taxpayers making charitable donations. Click here to read the full article. About Hale E. Sheppard HALE E. SHEPPARD, Esq. (B.S., M.A., J.D., LL.M., LL.M.T.) is a Shareholder in the Tax Controversy Section of Chamberlain Hrdlicka and Chair of the International Tax Group.

Conservation Easements, Partners, and Qualified Amended Returns

Image
  The IRS is sending mixed messages when it comes to potential resolution of disputes involving partnerships that engaged in a so-called syndicated conservation easement transaction (SCET). On one hand, the IRS has taken several enforcement actions recently, which make it procedurally  impossible for an individual partner to voluntarily resolve matters with the IRS and remain penalty-free by submitting a qualified amended return (QAR). On the other hand, the IRS commissioner issued two news releases in November and December, warning taxpayers of increased  enforcement activities and “encouraging” them to file QARs. This apparent inconsistency has many in the tax community confused and unable to properly advise partners, partnerships, and others. The good news is that the regulations seem to grant the commissioner authority to modify the QAR rules as necessary. This article reviews SCET issues; explains ongoing enforcement tools; summarizes recent IRS announcements urging ...

Conservation Easement Battles: The IRS Uses Syndication Expenses and Forms 8283 to Disallow Deductions

Image
The IRS takes the stance that any error or omission in connection with Form 8283, regardless of how minor, merits a deduction of $0. The IRS has recently added new layers to this argument. It now contends that some partnerships are not properly accounting for “syndication expenses,” which  leads to unwarranted deductions and/or inaccurate basis information on Form 8283, which impairs the IRS’s ability to detect non-compliance, which justifies complete disallowance of charitable deductions. This article analyzes issues relevant to this expanded position by the IRS. Read the full article here. About Hale E. Sheppard HALE E. SHEPPARD, Esq. (B.S., M.A., J.D., LL.M., LL.M.T.) is a Shareholder in the Tax Controversy Section of Chamberlain Hrdlicka and Chair of the International Tax Group.

Lessons from an International tax dispute: Three Interrelated Cases, in Three Different Proceedings, Generating Three Separate Liabilities

Image
  Attention has been focused recently on conservation easement donations, micro-captive insurance, virtual currency, and other “hot” topics. Although not dominating the news cycle any longer, plenty of taxpayers continue hiding foreign assets, and the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”), with help from the Department of Justice (“DOJ”), still aggressively pursues them. What is remarkable about these international actions is that they sometimes trigger three interrelated disputes, occurring in three different venues, and generating three potentially large liabilities. Read the full article here. About Hale E. Sheppard HALE E. SHEPPARD, Esq. (B.S., M.A., J.D., LL.M., LL.M.T.) is a Shareholder in the Tax Controversy Section of Chamberlain Hrdlicka and Chair of the International Tax Group.

Conservation Easement Settlement: More Guidance, More Questions

Image
Uplifted by some recent Tax Court victories on “technical” issues in conservation easement disputes, and cognizant of the enormous amount of additional cases headed its way in the coming years, the IRS announced a settlement initiative in June. The agency first described the terms of the settlement initiative through two means: a public release and private offer letters to eligible partnerships. Not surprisingly, that initial guidance had several holes. The IRS tried to plug them in October 2020 by publishing a chief counsel notice, along with a second release. This article analyzes all the information provided thus far about the settlement initiative, identifying key issues that remain unaddressed by the IRS, whether strategically or inadvertently. Read the full article here. About Hale E. Sheppard HALE E. SHEPPARD, Esq. (B.S., M.A., J.D., LL.M., LL.M.T.) is a Shareholder in the Tax Controversy Section of Chamberlain Hrdlicka and Chair of the International Tax Group.

Clarifying the Reasonable-reliance Defense to Penalties in an E-Filing Era; An Analysis of Boyle, Haynes, Intress, and More

Image
Taxpayers often file their tax returns  late, the IRS penalizes them, and they  try to place the blame, rightly or wrongly,  on their attorneys, accountants, or return  preparers. In other words, taxpayers frequently  attempt to shirk penalties by  raising the reasonable-reliance-on-a-tax- professional defense. this is common  knowledge. What is not widely understood,  though, is that the Supreme Court  ruled many decades ago, in 1985, that  such a defense only applies in situations  where a return preparer gives erroneous  substantive tax or legal advice to a taxpayer,  not where the preparer simply  flubs the  ministerial task of meeting a  filing deadline. What is even more obscure  is the recent case, in 2019, extending  the historic Supreme Court decision  to cases where taxpayers rely on preparers  to e-file their returns, and something  goes awry. This article analyzes the gen...

Questions Remain About the Conservation Easement Settlement Initiative

Image
The IRS is attacking partnerships that donate conservation easements to charitable organizations and then pass along the corresponding tax deductions to their partners. In an effort to dispense with cases quickly and avoid addressing the key issue — valuation of easements — the IRS often raises a long list of technical arguments. These generally focus on unintentional flaws with the deed of conservation easement, the appraisal, or Form 8283, “Noncash Charitable Contributions.” To the dismay of many in the conservation, tax, and legal communities, the Tax Court has ruled in favor of the IRS on technical issues in several recent cases. The IRS, leveraging the momentum from its recent victories, issued a release in late June describing a potential path to resolution (the settlement initiative). The Tax Court has a backlog  of conservation easement cases, with many more to come; the IRS has limited resources; and the IRS knows that many of the technical issues it is currently exploitin...