Conservation Easements and Pine Mountain: Favorable Rulings by Court of Appeals and Pending Issues



The IRS has been riding high recently because of several Tax Court victories on “technical” issues in conservation easement disputes. However, several signs exist that the tide might be turning. One of these is the recent decision by the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in Pine Mountain Preserve, LLLP. This article explains the general rules related to conservation easement donations, critical facts from the case, analysis by the Tax Court, overlooked aspects of the initial decision, recent rulings by the Court of Appeals, issues that the Tax Court must now decide on remand, and the positive aspects of the case thus far for taxpayers making charitable donations.


About Hale E. Sheppard

HALE E. SHEPPARD, Esq. (B.S., M.A., J.D., LL.M., LL.M.T.) is a Shareholder in the Tax Controversy Section of Chamberlain Hrdlicka and Chair of the International Tax Group.

Popular posts from this blog

The Limited Partner Exception to SECA Taxes: Three Tax Court Decisions and Future Clashes

Image
  Ambiguity about when distributions to “limited partners” are exempt from self-employment taxes has existed for five decades. This vagueness has led to many disputes, including numerous cases now winding their way through the courts. The Tax Court has made some significant rulings already, but many of the key issues are far from resolved. This article, the latest in a series, summarizes the relevant law and regulations, describes the only precedential case on the books for many years, explains the Compliance Campaign launched by the IRS, analyzes three recent Tax Court decisions, and identifies several additional cases on the way. Read the full article here. About Hale E. Sheppard HALE E. SHEPPARD, Esq. (B.S., M.A., J.D., LL.M., LL.M.T.)  is a partner at Eversheds Sutherland.  He defends clients in tax audits, tax appeals, and Tax Court litigation, covering both domestic and international issues.
Read more

Evaluating Three Conservation Easement Settlement Offers

Image
Conservation easement disputes have lasted nearly a decade and the end is far for clear. What is apparent, though, is that the IRS is now eager conclude as many cases as possible, and fast. Why? The IRS might be concerned about losing a major case on valuation issues, which could unleash many taxpayer victories in later cases. Another possibility is that the IRS wants to clear its massive inventory of existing SCET cases. Yet another motive might be that battling sophisticated taxpayers in high-dollar, complex, document-intensive cases takes a serious toll on the IRS. The true reasons for the IRS’s desire to resolve conservation easement cases now is not particularly important; what matters is understanding the relevant settlement programs and their nuances. This article, which expands on several of my earlier ones, compares and contrasts three different IRS programs. Read the full article here. About Hale E. Sheppard HALE E. SHEPPARD, Esq. (B.S., M.A., J.D., LL.M., LL.M.T.)  is a ...
Read more

Energy Efficient Commercial Building Property and Section 179D: New Case Offers Guidance on Allocations of Deductions

Image
  Disputes will arise when Congress enacts a tax incentive, it orders the IRS to supply details via regulations, the IRS publishes Notices instead, the Notices contemplate participation by multiple parties and the liberal allocation of tax benefits among them, the IRS issues guidance over the years echoing the Notices, and then the IRS suddenly changes its tune. This is exactly what has occurred when it comes to tax deductions for expenses related to Energy Efficient Commercial Building Property. This article provides an overview of Section 179D, explains various sources of IRS guidance from the past two decades, and analyzes the newest Tax Court case on point, Johnson v. Commissioner. Read the full article here. About Hale E. Sheppard HALE E. SHEPPARD, Esq. (B.S., M.A., J.D., LL.M., LL.M.T.) is a Shareholder in the Tax Controversy Section of Chamberlain Hrdlicka and Chair of the International Tax Group.
Read more